Wicked! But Not Wicked good

I really wanted to see the musical Wicked when it was at the Paramount last month. But I didn’t want it enough to ante up the massive ticket price so instead I figured that for free, I could get an enjoyable experience from reading the book. Sadly, I was very much mistaken.

The concept of the novel, by Gregory Maguire, is excellent. It follows the infamous Wicked Witch of the West (of the land of Oz, if you’re living under a rock) through her life, from her birth to horrified parents to her memorable death scene. Everything you might have wondered about Oz is explained here, such as the back-story of the flying monkeys and the true meaning of Dorothy’s slippers. Often the explanations for events from the original story have a dark overtone, and a shadow of political corruption and doom hangs over the entirety of the witch Elphaba’s tale.

However, the actual writing does not live up to its promise. The writing style is unbearably wordy, as if the author is trying to prove that to the readers that he has a perfect SAT vocabulary. Full of quasi-psychological ideas, the storyline is frequently bogged down and agonizing to read. And the 400-page length is unbearable; after about 200 pages of her travels, the story starts to feel meaningless and defeating. There are many great characters and ideas here, but the main character cancels them out. Elphaba is usually self-important, dogmatic, and self-pitying, which in turn made her impossible to care for.

I’ve heard that the musical is amazing, and maybe one day I’ll get the chance to see it and compare it to this dreadful book. But in the mean time, to get my Oz fix, I’ll rewatch the classic movie. I also highly recommend the original book to remedy the bad taste Wicked left in my mouth.

-Margaret K.

6 thoughts on “Wicked! But Not Wicked good

  1. Wally

    I liked the book, and its two sequels. Yes, they’re sometimes wordy, but I think the author is writing that way for a reason. There is still a lot of humor and intrigue, and while I agree Elphaba is a difficult character to admire, she does have her good points.
    In any case, I liked your review!

    Reply
  2. Lee

    I really loved Wicked and the sequel, although I have yet to read the 3rd. The language is definitely affected, but I feel like it goes with the story. I also like your candid review though. We could probably have a good heated debate about it–if it weren’t so long since I read it…

    Reply
  3. Tiffany

    I enjoyed the book, but can see all the reasons that another person might not like it. However, I have heard that the musical strays a LOT from the plot of the book, so if you get a chance to see it, you should. Most people I know who did not like the book, loved the musical.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s